All praise is for Allaah, Lord of the Universe. May peace and blessings be upon the one who was sent as a mercy to all of mankind.
It has become apparent that this certain musa millington, may Allaah guide him, is very notorious to refute anyone and everyone in the name of Salafiyah. After much contemplation and deliberation, it is very important that his mistakes and misguided methodology of jarh is exposed. Since his Islamic academic credentials are unknown but he imposing himself upon the ummah of trinidad to accept from him the explaination or give rulings is a reprehensible and disgraceful acts. Along side that he is all to eager to refute the salafees in the name of defending salafee and obligates the ummah to accept blindly words of any scholar he follows. This is purely hizbiyah. This is Hizbiyah, this is hizbiyah. In regards to atrocious and malicious campaign against the madeenah.com by the “vanguards of salafiyah” in the west, the esteemed shakykh Khalid has responded and warned them.
To make matters simple and clear for those in whose heart there is sickness or of those whose eyes blinded by the hizb and tasub, madeenah.com website is supervisied by Shaykh Khalid Raadaadee. Anyone previously objected or refuted the content of the site or has been known to involve openly or secretly warning against the site should repent as the website is associated with esteemed shaykh. Slandering or warning against the website in itself be accounted as though they are warning against the esteeemd salafe shaykh. There are numerous tazkiyah for the website from the very well known scholars such as Shaykh Wasiullah and Shaykh Suhaymee, may Allaah preserve them both.
If there are any issues related to the translators of the articles on the website cannot be attributed to the website or to the shaykh since this has been clarified by the shaykh hafidullah.
Along with that neither madeenah.com is related to my blog nor am I with them, just merely republishing their beneficial articles should not be construed as partnership or any association. I ask people to fear Allaah and speak the words of justice. Beware of tale carriers and fitnah mongers, may Allaah protect us from the hasad of hasadeen, ameen.
The Response of The Shaykh
All praise is for Allaah, Lord of the Universe. May peace and blessings be upon the one who was sent as a mercy to all of mankind.
A series of articles have recently been published by certain malicious websites defaming Madeenah.com in addition to the students of knowledge who contribute to it. Those responsible for these articles have proliferated them with lies and slander as well as attempts to reach conclusions based upon inadequate and twisted evidence.
Those responsible for these websites have made many claims and allegations that in reality have no basis to them; rather they are mere statements of delusion based upon weak and unfounded arguments. Along with this, they have judged the intentions [of those students involved with Madeenah.com], such as their claim that the objective behind establishing the website was to attack Salafi Publications, that their agenda is to bring Salafi Publications down at all costs, that they try to exploit the scholars to fulfill their hate-filled agenda, and that they are not sincere in their intentions and actions. No doubt, these are false claims that contain evil accusations about one’s intentions and objectives, all of which have been forbidden in the noble Sharee’ah.
In fact, they went as far as attributing to the students of knowledge who contribute to the website heinous statements of defamation without any clear proof or evidence, such as saying that they are mischief makers, treacherous, deceptive, that they play politics with the Scholars in a manner characteristic of al-Ikhwan al-Muslimeen and other than that from false and heinous descriptions in the name of sincere advice and refutation.
It is unfortunate that all of this has resulted in preoccupying the people with matters that do not benefit them, and in wasting time with gossip and hearsay. I therefore felt it was appropriate to write this brief note with the intention of offering sincere advice, establishing the truth and removing the falsehood, hoping that Allaah will cause it to be of benefit.
In relation to the articles that have been written and published on Madeenah.com by the noble brothers Nadir Ahmed, Tahir Wyatt and Mohammed Akhtar, this was only done after having been summarized and read to me before being distributed. I then granted them permission to publish the articles in order to defend the website and uphold the truth. These articles contain in them a defense against the claim that Madeenah.com ‘attacks The Salafees.’ They – may Allaah bless them – made clear that no particular group or organization has a monopoly upon Salafiyyah. This is a problem that people in many countries complain about and not one restricted to America, Canada or Britain. The brothers also explained that to clarify a mistake and transmit sincere advice from the scholars should not be made out to be ‘an attack.’ As a result of these articles, the false claims levied against the website have become clear.
The articles that the brothers wrote (may Allaah bless them) included within them a number of requests to those who were making such claims; the essence of them being to provide evidence that this website (Madeenah.com) ‘attacks The Salafees.’ [The accusers] replied by writing a number of flimsy refutations that were void of any substantial answer.
Since they were unable to produce a knowledge-based reply, they resorted to false allegations, slander, judging one’s intentions and attempting to reach conclusions that lack evidence. Even [some] of the people of knowledge and virtue were not saved from their criticism, as they accused Shaykh Waseeullah Abbaas (may Allaah preserve him) of not being prepared to accept the truth from them and that his opposition to Salafi Publications is due to his affinity for Jami’yyah Ahl al-Hadeeth, along with other false accusations and evil thoughts.
They then exceeded even this by raising doubt about whether or not “Shaykh Khaalid” really knows what’s happening on the website, further claiming that the website promotes innovators, hizbis, Ikhwaanees, and Takfeerees without the Shaykh being aware, and that it shows leniency, gentleness, and a close relationship towards them whilst being harsh against the Salafees.
Upon what basis have these people ruled that “Shaykh Khaalid” is unaware of what happens on the website? Does he not read what is [published] on the website even though the overwhelming majority of it is [also available] in Arabic?! And where is the evidence that the website promotes innovators, hizbis, Ikhwaanees, and Takfeerees?!
Say: bring forth your evidences if you are truthful
And how could they possibly bring any evidence?!
Do they realize that their claim that the website promotes the people of innovation contains a malicious insult upon the Mashayikh and scholars who have praised and recommended the website; accusing them of being ignorant, negligent and naïve? Are these the manners that are shown to the People of Knowledge & Virtue?! To Allaah is the complaint.
On top of this, they have accused their brothers of that which they did not say. They mentioned repeatedly that the brothers are attacking The Salafis under the banner of refuting the opposer (ar-radd alaa al-mukhaalif). However, the reality is contrary to what they have said. This term ‘refuting the opposer’ has never been mentioned at all by the brothers in their writings; in fact they never even wrote a ‘refutation’, rather they only sought to defend the website from what was falsely and deceptively attributed to it.
This is an example of the lies and slanders that were written by the one who shamelessly writes on ‘Salafi Publications’ website. It is hoped that this individual reveals his name, since we do not believe that everyone who cooperates with Salafi Publications resorts to these deceitful and treacherous methods. We would hope that Salafi Publications free themselves – and they should – if, in fact, a particular individual is using their name to spread these lies and false claims.
The reality is that these people are unable to author a proper reply and hence have resorted to causing turmoil amongst people; they try to defame the Salafee students of knowledge who are graduates from the University [of Madeenah] through means of slander and mockery. They also accuse them of not understanding the methodology of the Salaf, in fact not even valuing it even though they have spent many years in the University.
No doubt, the graduates of the University who left behind their families and their countries in order to traverse the path of seeking knowledge have a status that should be held in high esteem, respected and preserved. I therefore encourage the Muslims in the West to benefit from them and not allow this commotion and defamation from Salafi Publications to be a barrier that prevents them from benefitting from them [the graduates] and maintaining contact with them.
Also, there are some important points and guidelines that I wish to emphasize with regards to those who translate for [Madeenah.com] so that everyone may be aware of them. From amongst them:
1. It is a condition that the translator is a graduate from the Islamic University of Madeenah.
2. The one who is currently studying at the University, or did not complete his studies therein, will only have his translated works accepted after they have been checked by a graduate.
3. The name, country, address and faculty of study of the translator must be known at the time of his participation with the website. No one unknown or anonymous is allowed to translate on the site.
4. If a translator falls into error and makes mistakes, this does not necessitate that his translation is removed or censured.
5. An emphasis that the website is not responsible whatsoever for statements and actions specific to any particular translator. Rather the avenue of sincere advice remains open if it is indeed established that he has made a mistake deserving of admonition. Thus, it is totally incorrect that the website or the rest of the translators are held responsible for activities specific to a particular translator. Madeenah.com is only responsible for that which is published on the website.
We would also like to point out that our website does not have any connection to Jami’yyah Ahl al-Hadeeth, Jami’yyah Ihya at-Turaath nor any other organization, establishment or Jami’yyah; we do not defend any of them at all. Refer to what we said some years ago.
The allegations of Salafi Publications that we defend these organizations is a lie which has no truth to it. Their pathetic efforts to link [Madeenah.com] to Jami’yyah Ahl al-Hadeeth because of a particular translator delivering a lecture with someone else who delivers lectures in a Masjid connected to the Jami’yyah, or other forms of inadequate proof, is simply a futile attempt to link together that which is not connected.
Our speech regarding the Jami’yyah is clear and has been present on the website for six years. So these brothers should fear Allaah with regards to their brothers and their Mashayikh, and let them leave alone these treacherous, deceptive methods.
In conclusion, we would like to offer advice for everybody and remind them of the following:
1. To maintain manners and knowledge when advising. The scholars are not free from falling into mistakes, and students of knowledge are even more prone to this. However sincere advice should be given in the correct prescribed manners, based upon evidences and proofs, not based upon suspicion and questioning people’s intentions and the spreading of lies. I remind them of the statement of the Prophet (sal Allaahu alayhi wa sallam) to Usaamah bin Zayd (may Allaah be pleased with them both) when he killed a man he thought had only proclaimed ‘Laa ilaaha illa Allaah’ due to his fear of being killed. The Prophet (sal Allaahu alayhi wa sallam) said to him:
Did you split open his heart to find out whether he truly meant what he said or not?
2. To be distant from suspicion, false doubts, tracking people’s mistakes and falsely accusing brothers with lies and accusations. I remind you of the statement of the Messenger of Allaah (sal Allaahu alayhi wa sallam):
O community of people, who have believed by their tongue, and belief has not entered their hearts; do not backbite Muslims, and do not search for their faults, for if anyone searches for their faults, Allaah will search for his fault, and if Allaah searches for the fault of anyone, He [will] disgrace him [even] in his own home.
3. To attach importance to knowledge and to that which benefits one in his religious and worldly affairs. Indeed the Prophet (sal Allaahu alayhi wa sallam) said:
Concentrate on those matters that will benefit you, and seek Allaah’s assistance.
And the Prophet (sal Allaahu alayhi wa sallam) also said:
From the goodness of a person’s Islam is to leave alone that which does not concern him.
4. To distance yourselves from insults, curses and vulgar speech. Indeed the Prophet (sal Allaahu alayhi wa sallam) forbade from this and he said:
The believer is not one who slanders, curses, or speaks in an obscene or foul manner.
He (sal Allaahu alayhi wa sallam) also said:
To insult a Muslim is disobedience, and to kill him is disbelief.
5. We also remind them of what we have repeatedly stated: whoever has any observations regarding the contents of the website then let him send them to us, and we will accept and welcome them with an open heart. We only stipulate that the observations are based upon clear evidence and not suspicion and doubt, nor false impositions.
May Allaah guide us all to that which He loves and is pleased with Our last call is that all praise is for Allaah the Lord of the Universe
Khaalid bin Qaasim ar-Raddaadee
Member of the Teaching Faculty at the Islamic University of Madeenah
Supervisor of Madeenah.com
28 Jumaada al-Awwal 1432 / 1 May 2011
 (3.1, p.5) ‘… this group was formed to attack Salafi Publications.’
(1, p.3) ‘They were not really united in their hearts, but only came together because each one of them had a common interest in countering the da’wah of Salafi Publications’
 (2, p.10) ‘… but they won’t speak out because of what they see to be a higher, loftier agenda, which is to attack Salafi Publications and to bring them down at all costs so their da’wah ‘
(1, p.3) ‘…they actively sought the downfall of Sala” Publications and their efforts. ‘
 (1, p.13) ‘ … their hate-filled agenda to mobilize the Scholars against Salafi Publications’
(2, p.12) ‘… their hate-filled agenda to mobilize the Scholars against Salafi Publications’
 (2, p.10 FN) ‘… there is no honesty in their actions that one can point to’
(1, p.2) ‘It was easy for many of them to be mobilized by others whose intentions were not so sincere…’
 (1, p.2) ‘these individuals have turned out to be mischief makers’
(1, p.13) ‘In truth, they were really creating mischief’
 (2, p.6) ‘This is talbees (deception) and khiyaanah (treachery)’
 (2, p.10 FN) ‘… these people are mulabbisoon (deceivers)’
 (2, p.8) ‘It backfired upon them leading them to start playing politics with the Scholars in a manner characteristic of al-Ikhwan al-Muslimeen.’
 (2, p. 3) ‘In reality, the Shaykh either dismissed all of the evidences and was not prepared to accept any criticism of the Jam’iyyah, or he made excuses for the ones which simply could not be dismissed.’
(2, p. 4) ‘… naturally Shaykh Waseeullaah has an affinity for the Jam’iyyah Ahl al-Hadeeth UK and his opposition to Salafi Publications is largely driven by this affinity.’
 (1, p.6-7 FN) ‘…the real question is what is the level of two-facedness they are showing to Shaykh Khaalid and to what extent Shaykh Khaalid is really aware of their activities and their associations, promotions and allegiances with the hizbiyyeen…’
 (3.0, p.1) ‘A Look at the Da’wah and Manhaj of the Madeenah.Com / FatwaOnline Group and Their Support Of, Allegiance to or Cooperation with the Hizbis and Innovators’
(3.1, p.4 FN) ‘Rather we say clearly that Madeenah.Com’s support and promotion of these gatherings where callers to takfeer and hizbiyyah gather is in opposition to the Salafi manhaj’
(3.1, p.1) ‘Promoting the Events Organized by the Followers of Ikhwani Innovators’
 (3.1, p.2) ‘All of this clearly shows us that Madeenah.com’s agenda was and still remains accommodation of the people of hizbiyyah and enmity towards Salafi Publications and those who cooperate and associate with them’
(2, p.3) ‘Their manhaj was and is one of toleration of deviations in the manhaj, cooperation with enemies of the da’wah and its scholars.’
 Al-Baqarah: 135
 (1, p.2) ‘The general theme of these articles is the claim that the various statements published on Madeenah.Com in criticism of Salafi Publications are from the intent and angle of refuting the opposer (ar-radd alaa al-mukhaalif) and are not to be considered “attacking the Salafis”.’
(1, p.10) ‘One would assume then – since Madeenah.com (and Fatwaonline.com) have spent so much effort in trying to bring out the mistakes of Salafi Publications and continue to highlight them under their claimed banner of “refuting the opposer” –‘
(1, p.10) ‘The So-Called Claim of “Refuting the Opposer”’
 (3.2, p.16) ‘…there are many, many individual incidents and issues which in and of themselves indicate the dishonesty, double-standards, blatant hypocrisy (in action) of Madeenah.Com, which as someone said is more deserving of being called Madeenah.Con’
(3.1, p.6) “ these dotcom students “
(2, p.6) ‘Were these “students of Madinah” so naive, ignorant and dumb-witted that they did not anticipate what their distribution of this baseless speech of Shaykh Waseeullaah‘
(3.1, p.4 footnote) ‘This is another example of the deceptive manhaj of these Madeenah students of presenting generalized’
 (3.2, p.9) ‘You have to really get behind the thinking in this email and you have to realize that these Madeenah.Com students spend four, six or more years in Madeenah and yet have learned very little in terms of the Salafi manhaj, because the truth is that they don’t value it, and thus there is little zeal for them to grasp it, learn it and take it and act upon its necessities (things which follow on from it).’
 (2, p.2) ‘Madeenah.Com are in complete support and defense of the Markaz Jam’iyyah Ahl al-Hadeeth UK, Green Lane Mosque’
(2, p.2) ‘the reader will see straight through this smokescreen and recognize the fact that the agenda of Madeenah.com was to defend and bolster support for the Jam’iyyah and Green Lane Mosque’
|Translator: Naveed Ayaaz, Abul Abbaas|
|Date Published: Tuesday, 03 May 2011|
|This article has been read 1,958 times|
|Print this article|
|This article has been published with the permission of the translator, who affirms the accuracy of his translation of this article as well as the authenticity of the original Arabic source. Should you have any comment(s) and/or correction(s) to suggest, please write to us at: